Most Hilariously Failed Attempts at Sexy Album Covers. THE BROS-CHOCOLATE BOX. This album's title song reveals that the "Chocolate Box" refers to the singer telling some fine woman that he does not want to be treated like "the first chocolate in the box" before she moves on to some other dude. But we don't care who you are, where you're from, or how open-minded you are about sexuality: When you see that picture, you're forced to assume "chocolate box" is referring to a dude's butthole.