Pimento Cheese 4 oz cream cheese 4 oz diced pimento 2 oz mayonnaise 8 oz sharp white Cheddar cheese. Place cream cheese and mayonnaise into large mixing bowl and beat at medium until thoroughly combined. Add cheddar. Mix till combined, add pimentos season with salt and pepper. Feel free to substitute type of cheese for additional flavor. Substitute 2 oz blue cheese for 2 oz of the sharp white Cheddar. Substitute another pepper or flavor for the 2 oz of pimentos.